Congressman continues pressuring U.S. to stop fueling “civilian carnage” in Saudi-led war in Yemen

October 19, 2016
In The News

U.S. is likely complicit in "horrifying" Saudi war crimes in Yemen, Rep. Ted Lieu warned John Kerry in a new letter

A congressman is calling on Secretary of State John Kerry to halt U.S. support for the destructive Saudi-led bombing campaign in Yemen.

Rep. Ted Lieu, D-Calif., sent Kerry a letter last week calling for the U.S. to “cease immediately the aiding and abetting of” Saudi forces.

“The continuing civilian carnage caused by the Saudi Arabia-led military coalition in Yemen is horrifying,” Lieu wrote in the letter, a copy of which was obtained by Salon.

“It appears that either the Saudi coalition is intentionally targeting civilians or they are not distinguishing between civilians and military targets. Both would be war crimes,” he stressed.

Since March 2015, a coalition of 10 Middle Eastern countries led by Saudi Arabia and armed and supported by the U.S. and U.K. has been bombing Yemen, the poorest country in the Middle East.

At least 10,000 Yemenis have been killed in the war, including more than 4,100 civilians, according to the U.N. Western-backed airstrikes have been responsible for nearly two-thirds of the civilian casualties, the U.N. has repeatedly reported.

Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have documented at least 70 illegal airstrikes on civilians carried out by the coalition, Lieu noted in his letter, which was sent on Oct. 11.

A U.N. panel of experts also documented coalition attacks on a variety of civilian targets, including hospitals, schools, homes and refugee camps.

“The frequency and scale of the civilian killings by the Saudi military coalition make it difficult to come to any conclusion other than that war crimes have been and are continuing to be committed in Yemen,” Lieu wrote.

“The repeated and frequent strikes on civilians show that the issue is not the gross incompetence of the Saudi military coalition,” he said. “Apologists for the Saudi coalition can perhaps defend a few errant bombs, but not over 70 unlawful airstrikes.”

The U.S. has refueled thousands of Saudi warplanes and provided intelligence to the coalition. The Obama administration has also sold billions of dollars worth of weapons to Saudi Arabia, some of which have been used to kill Yemeni civilians.

In his letter, Lieu warned that the atrocities could help extremists. The U.S.-backed war has also helped al-Qaida grow in Yemen, and even Islamic State forces have entered the country, seizing on the chaos.

“The aiding and abetting of Saudi airstrikes on civilians is a potential recruiting tool for terrorists,” Lieu wrote. “Every U.S. assisted bomb that kills children, doctors, patients, newlyweds and funeral mourners has the potential to amplify hatred towards the U.S.”

One of the worst massacres in the war was carried out Oct. 8. The Saudi-led coalition bombed a funeral in Sanaa, Yemen’s capital, killing more than 140 people and wounding at least 600.

Human Rights Watch said the attack was an apparent war crime using U.S.-made bombs, and called for an immediate independent investigation. An Oxfam America official called the “massacre of civilians” a “gruesome act” and accused Saudi Arabia of “using U.S. support to legitimize its heinous conduct and deflect international criticism.”

The Saudi-led coalition eventually admitted that the attack was intentional, but blamed it on “false information” that Yemeni rebel leaders were present. The coalition is fighting Yemen’s Houthi rebels and allied militias loyal to former Yemeni president Ali Abdullah Saleh.

On Tuesday, Rep. Lieu released a statement condemning the attack on the funeral. “The Saudi-led military coalition has now essentially admitted to committing war crimes,” he said. “The civilian funeral ceremony was the intended target of the Saudi coalition.”

Lieu pointed out that even if rebel leaders were present, “that would not justify an airstrike that targeted more than 650 civilians.” According to the law of armed conflict, military force cannot be used if it will cause disproportionate civilian casualties.

“This airstrike is yet another example of a disturbing pattern where the Saudi coalition drops bombs on civilian targets nowhere near military targets, or drops bombs killing a disproportionate number of civilians,” Lieu wrote.

He called for Saudi military officials to resign and to be investigated. He also again stressed that the U.S. “needs to immediately cease aiding and abetting a Saudi coalition that has committed war crimes.”

Lieu, who represents California’s 33rd Congressional District, mostly on the west side of Los Angeles, has been among the most outspoken critics of U.S. support for the war. Before becoming a lawmaker, Lieu served in the U.S. Air Force, during which time he taught the law of armed conflict.

Lieu’s letter to Kerry, who heads the government agency overseeing U.S. support for the war, is not his first. The congressman sent Kerry another similar letter in March. Lieu’s communications director told Salon that Kerry’s office has not responded to either of the letters.

Salon has reported on Lieu’s other attempts to raise concerns about the war in Yemen within the government.

In September, Lieu introduced a House bill to block a $1.15 billion U.S. arms deal with Saudi Arabia. The Senate version of the legislation failed to pass.

Internally, the State Department has expressed concerns about the war. Lieu cited in his new letter an investigation by Reuters, which obtained government records through Freedom of Information Act requests. The internal documents show that government lawyers warned officials that the U.S. might be implicated in Saudi war crimes in Yemen.

An email obtained by Reuters shows that Deputy Secretary of State Antony Blinken even held a meeting with U.S. officials in which they discussed “options to limit U.S. exposure to LOAC (Law of Armed Conflict) concerns” in the war in Yemen.

Despite internal concerns about complicity in war crimes, large U.S. weapons sales to Saudi Arabia continued. Since 2015, the Obama administration has done more than $20 billion in arms deals with the Saudi monarchy, and since 2009 the U.S. has offered more than $115 billion in weapons sales and military support.

In his new letter to Kerry, Lieu echoed the State Department officials’ concerns that the U.S. could potentially be implicated in war crimes in Yemen. He noted that the State Department has an office dedicated to preventing foreign war crimes. “The credibility of that office has been shredded by the U.S.-enabled airstrikes on civilians in Yemen,” he wrote.

The conflict in Yemen drags on, although the U.N. has been calling for a ceasefire. Both sides agreed to a 72-hour truce on Tuesday. The temporary cessation of hostilities will allow aid groups to deliver support to Yemen, which the U.N. says is going through one of the worst humanitarian crises in the world. More than half of the country, 14 million people, is going hungry, and at least 80 percent of Yemenis are in dire need of humanitarian aid.